So the dreaded meeting with "the powers that be" at the elementary has come and gone. (Teacher, principal, speech therapist, language specialist and special ed teacher. Funny-no ESL teacher.) I wasn't too surprised at the outcome.
The "language specialist" (a.k.a. young guy with bed head hair wearing sandals on this blustery 30 degree day) sat down and immediately pulled out an article that shows the parallels of lack of language skills and learning disabilities. It basically concludes that until a child has been in the country speaking for 2-3 years he is not articulate enough to assess for a learning disability. I can agree with this-somewhat. I'm not really thinking Alex has a learning disability-a speech disorder? Perhaps. Regardless can't he qualify for more one on one help during school?
(Hum? Grr....)
The "language specialist" (a.k.a. young guy with bed head hair wearing sandals on this blustery 30 degree day) sat down and immediately pulled out an article that shows the parallels of lack of language skills and learning disabilities. It basically concludes that until a child has been in the country speaking for 2-3 years he is not articulate enough to assess for a learning disability. I can agree with this-somewhat. I'm not really thinking Alex has a learning disability-a speech disorder? Perhaps. Regardless can't he qualify for more one on one help during school?
(Hum? Grr....)
I was proud of myself for being vocal and not emotional. I explained that my son was from an orphanage for children with "heavy speech disorders" and that I assured the court I would have his disorder assessed here in the States and follow up on it. We have been here almost ten months. Of course I don't have any documentation as to what sort of speech disorder he has. Nor do I have anything documenting precise learning disorders-only told he was a terrible student and hates to study. But my Alex is sometimes difficult to understand and I don't know it that's just a lack of language and his palate struggling with new sounds OR his speech disorder. One of the reason's for this meeting. I would like him tested so we can determine one way or the other. Is it his disorder or he just needs time to grasp the language? The speech therapist was very sympathetic but with the recommendation of the language specialist to wait for two-three years it doesn't look like we'll be getting a speech assessment anytime soon. Apparently testing cannot be done without the approval of this entire committee and I certainly don't have Mr. Bedhead on board. She further pointed out that perhaps if we point out his articulation issues that he'll feel self conscious and just stop talking or trying to communicate. I can agree with this to a point but what if some of his sounds that are hard to understand could simply be solved with a session from a professional that can show him were to put his tongue or move his lips or there's a simple, easy technique-that I don't know-to help him with certain sounds?
(Grrr...frustration)
(Grrr...frustration)
Everyone was oh so nice and offered to give ME any and all of the resources needed for ME to help him outside of school. Which is a lovely idea in itself except I ALREADY help him outside of school. Each day we work on his spelling, vocabulary, write in his journal-working on sentence structure, punctuation and more spelling-read & study his Lucky Listener in addition to read out loud for twenty minutes.
While walking with the special ed teacher to her room to get said materials I asked her how much time I could reasonably expect out of Alex outside of school for studying and she told me forty minutes to and hour......hum....we're already doing that and sometimes more!
While walking with the special ed teacher to her room to get said materials I asked her how much time I could reasonably expect out of Alex outside of school for studying and she told me forty minutes to and hour......hum....we're already doing that and sometimes more!
I got a little defensive when the principal told me "I realize Mrs. Richhart that you might be disappointed, that Alex might not be learning as fast as you'd like and that you are frustrated." I'm frustrated? I'm disappointed? "Let me be perfectly clear. I am not disappointed in Alex. I think he's doing fabulous-but he needs more help-one on one during school." His poor teacher cannot give him this-she is fabulous and so in my corner. (Which is what I felt like-like I was in the ring and fighting Mr. Bedhead. Without his approval, nothing can be done?) I further went on to explain that unlike most ESL students, Alex's native language is not spoken at home. In fact he cannot remember how to speak Ukraine. He can understand some of it in his head but cannot find the words to speak back. Totally normal for his age and given he doesn't have anyone to speak to in his language on a daily bases. So it's not like if he doesn't understand something WE can explain it to him in his native language and at this point-explaining it to him in his language may or may not be any clearer than explaining it to him in English!
Mr. Bedhead referred to the many older adopted kids that are currently at the Junior High. I pointed out that they are ALL significantly older, from a gifted and talented orphanage (or at least I was once told that) and that they have a network of children all from the same school living in the same area and have retained their language.
We don't have this.
We don't have this.
Now in all fairness, he DOES get some help already. He has thirty minutes three times a week with the ESL teacher, a special computer program in his class room that he does when the subject being taught is just way beyond him or when he has some free time, and sometimes he has a tutor listen to him read. But in my mind-correct me if I'm wrong-I cannot expect more than an hour more of study outside of school-why can't we make his time IN school more productive? Why can't he be pulled out to work on English comprehension or fractions or sentence structure by trained and qualified individuals. (Unlike me. Theater major. Mom. Real Estate Agent. Anyone who's followed my blog for long can attest that English is not my forte!) Why can't he get more than a hour and a half a week of additional help? Why not make his day at school specific to his needs?
I was hoping for help during this last year and three months he has remaining in elementary as I know how junior high is. Seven classes, seven teachers with hundreds of students. He's going to get chewed up and spit out. Heaven help us.
But as it stands, no testing or assessments until he's been here for at least two years-which will be just a month shy of getting out of elementary.
(More Grrr..)
But as it stands, no testing or assessments until he's been here for at least two years-which will be just a month shy of getting out of elementary.
(More Grrr..)
I did tell them that I'm not trying to pawn him off on them-and expect them to take care of it all. We DO work at home, EVERYDAY! But there are so many subjects covered during the day-like history-that he's not grasping and sits there bored and/or bothering his classmates. Why not get him some further language comprehension help or address some of the math skills he's lacking?
Later, I emailed everyone this article about language and the older internationally adopted child.
http://pages.towson.edu/sglennen/Olderchildrenandlanguage.htm
One line in this article cries out to me and certainly applies to our situation- and is why I pushed for the meeting in the first place!
Parents need to advocate for their children and remind professionals that
the internationally adopted child’s first language, and only language, is
now English. If the child is not proficient in English, the child is not
proficient in any language and therefore at significant academic risk.
Am I done? Heck no! I fortunately have a fabulous friend who just happens to be a speech therapist and she's agreed to test him as a favor to me. It won't be official but it will be something. My hopes are that he'll test well and whatever speech disorder he has doesn't manifest its self in the English language. (I was told by our adoption facilitator that the sound he struggles with is not a sound needed in English?) Then I can relax a little and know "in two to three years" he will be articulate. If not I can at least take my results back to the school for round two in the ring.
Later, I emailed everyone this article about language and the older internationally adopted child.
http://pages.towson.edu/sglennen/Olderchildrenandlanguage.htm
One line in this article cries out to me and certainly applies to our situation- and is why I pushed for the meeting in the first place!
Parents need to advocate for their children and remind professionals that
the internationally adopted child’s first language, and only language, is
now English. If the child is not proficient in English, the child is not
proficient in any language and therefore at significant academic risk.
Am I done? Heck no! I fortunately have a fabulous friend who just happens to be a speech therapist and she's agreed to test him as a favor to me. It won't be official but it will be something. My hopes are that he'll test well and whatever speech disorder he has doesn't manifest its self in the English language. (I was told by our adoption facilitator that the sound he struggles with is not a sound needed in English?) Then I can relax a little and know "in two to three years" he will be articulate. If not I can at least take my results back to the school for round two in the ring.
We've adjusted a few things at home to incorporate more English into our routine. We've eliminated him reading the "Lucky Listener" which was reading out loud long passages about the Constitution or the US government. We've replaced that with 2nd grade worksheets with a lot of basic English concepts. Three of them each day.
Tuesday night I asked a certain older sister to help Alex with the worksheets as I had church commitments. When I got home-late-everything was done incorrectly. Big sis DID give him the assignments but apparently little or no instruction. The next morning before school I sat down with him and we went back over and erased and re-did. I realized that each morning Alex-who is a morning person-gets up, gets ready and has 30-40 minutes of unstructured time that is usually spent playing on the piano or petting the cat or dog. This morning I got him working on his worksheets. He did AMAZING. One worksheet had words grouped together like vanilla, chocolate, strawberry and then a list of words that described the group of words (flavor being the answer) and he did great! Mornings are defiantly the time to work on this.
Standing beside him as he sat at the bar, I told him how awesome he did and reflected.
Me: Alex, where were you last year at this time?
Alex: In Ukraine.
Me: Yes, and look at you now. Less than a year later. In America. Doing English worksheets so very, very well. You should be so proud of yourself. You are amazing. Are you proud of yourself?
Alex: (Beaming with a big grin nodded and wrapped his arm around my waist and leaned in to hug me) I proud of you Mom, teach me English.
Me: I'm proud of me too!
Later, I clarified that if we do our worksheets in the morning then we won't have to do them at night, freeing up some time and craziness at night. He was relieved to learn my new morning study session idea was not in ADDITION to what we were already doing after school and at night. As he finished up the last worksheet he said:
"I'm good with that!"
Like he'd been speaking English forever....
Tuesday night I asked a certain older sister to help Alex with the worksheets as I had church commitments. When I got home-late-everything was done incorrectly. Big sis DID give him the assignments but apparently little or no instruction. The next morning before school I sat down with him and we went back over and erased and re-did. I realized that each morning Alex-who is a morning person-gets up, gets ready and has 30-40 minutes of unstructured time that is usually spent playing on the piano or petting the cat or dog. This morning I got him working on his worksheets. He did AMAZING. One worksheet had words grouped together like vanilla, chocolate, strawberry and then a list of words that described the group of words (flavor being the answer) and he did great! Mornings are defiantly the time to work on this.
Standing beside him as he sat at the bar, I told him how awesome he did and reflected.
Me: Alex, where were you last year at this time?
Alex: In Ukraine.
Me: Yes, and look at you now. Less than a year later. In America. Doing English worksheets so very, very well. You should be so proud of yourself. You are amazing. Are you proud of yourself?
Alex: (Beaming with a big grin nodded and wrapped his arm around my waist and leaned in to hug me) I proud of you Mom, teach me English.
Me: I'm proud of me too!
Later, I clarified that if we do our worksheets in the morning then we won't have to do them at night, freeing up some time and craziness at night. He was relieved to learn my new morning study session idea was not in ADDITION to what we were already doing after school and at night. As he finished up the last worksheet he said:
"I'm good with that!"
Like he'd been speaking English forever....

9 of my blog friends said something...:
VERY frustrating! What grade is he in? When I was teaching I had a boy from Pakistan who got LOADS of services. Do you have a university nearby? We had many education students come in, read 1 on 1 with him, teach him math concepts, do reading flash cards, all sorts of activities. Although this was 1st grade, I still think 1 on 1 would be a great addition to his day. I hate jumping through the hoops of school departments... erg.
Can he qualify for an IEP? I know that there are ways to go against principals that a couple of my friends used (AZ and CO). Our son has presented pbs as I had shared with you a while back which have to do with his eyes. We took him for the 3rd time to an auditory processing test which was more in depth this time(he has been followed by an ENT for 9 yrs!!!!) and we finally found out that his left ear somehow does not connect anything to the brain. So instructors should speak to him on his right side!!! It took 4 years to get a correct vision diagnosis. I understand your frustration. Hang in there! There are always solutions.
I feel for you I have been nicely pushing to get Tanya and IEP. Where she was diagnosed in Nov. with PTSD and RAD (neglect and abusethey were forced to do an IEP to help her. (Before they were saying she was an ESL student not special needs, but with her trama she is sp ed, she really is behind, at first grade level) To test her they have to do it in her own language... maybe you can see if they would test him in his own language to see if he has a speech issue. I've been told 3-8 years to get a grasp on a new language, how else are they expected to learn w/o extra English for the next 8 years? Don't give up, even talk to ESL teachers and speach teachers in other schools to find out if there are tests and stuff that can be done. Our kids have one on one in reading, spelling and math at school, but it is science and history that is killing Tanya in JR. high (she's never had those classes before and her orphanage was for slow children, they only attended 4 hours a day!). We are trying to get her help in these other classes...
From things he's told you about Ukraine he could have PTSD, they have to do an IEP for that. We adore our therapist, but not covered by inurance! Good Luck.
Ugh...that sounds terrible. I loved the info about how a child who no longer speaks their original language now has English as their first language...it was very interesting and you can see how quickly they would fall behind academically if they are caught between two languages. Keep up the fight :)
JADIP: He did have one mom volunteer coming in to read with him a couple times a week but he hurt her feelings when she came to read and he thought he would be missing science experiments. He told her in that Ukraine gruff voice that pierces your soul that NO HE WILL NOT READ. He got in big trouble at home, lost video game privileges, wrote a very sweet apology note-on his own but she has never returned. I think it was this BEHAVIOR that triggered getting him on the "docket" for assessment. But since our big talk he's been much better in class and so now not a behavior issue.
Hale:I'll certainly be looking in to IEP after his speech test. If he has a speech impediment, it's ridiculous to wait 2-3 years before addressing it....right?
Carlin: You're right. I should have mentioned in my post that 2-3 years is just to communicate and be properly assessed for a learning disability. I was told 6-8 to be fluent and even then not in a specified field like medical or mechanical.
I should have had him tested in his native tongue within 3 months of arriving. He sincerely cannot speak Ukraine. He cannot even tell me the work for salt of shoe. I know with the three of yours they have each other to speak to and keep it going but Alex until the last month or so has been almost "anti" Ukraine. He refused to speak even when I'd try to get him together with the other kids. He wanted nothing to do with his previous life. Lately we've been able to talk more about things he liked and Ukraine food etc and he's been trying to remember words and share them with us.
Hindsight is 20/20 and I should have had him tested earlier.(As I doubt they did any testing in Ukraine.) It's too late now. The only language he has now is English. I do think that their schooling in Ukraine was much more lax and certainly no one helped him with homework or really gave a damn. So I don't think he's slow as much as just neglected in his learning and now he's trying to catch up six grades of in one year in a new language? Or I guess in the next 2-3. Meanwhile his class gets further and further ahead. When does the gap close?
And why do I have to have a diagnoses when it's apparent that he needs help learning the language and/or there is proof he has a speech disorder.
He has TIME during the day that is wasted on subjects beyond his comprehension and professionals that have the knowledge and information to help him. Why can't they see that? Grrr.. Sorry, I'm venting.
Corbie: I feel like I've been sent back to my corner but I'm not knocked out! I'm just spitting in a bucket and getting my eye swabbed regrouping for the next round!
Wendy, I feel for you. This must be so frustrating. My 20 month old had a speech evaluation. I'm thinking if they can evaluate a 20 month old who is not very verbal they could probably figure out a way to evaluate Alex. This just doesn't seem right. At all. It's so great that he has a smart, dedicated, and persistant mom in his corner.
Wow! I don't have any sort of advice but can understand your frustration. All I can say is, hang in there and keep advocating for Alex the way you did. Way to be strong instead of emotional (the, I'm really angry but I'm crying instead little problemo must run in our fam!)He is so lucky to have a mom like you!!
Be the mama bear that you have to be. You have to advocate for your kids because no one else will. I think that you are doing a great job! That speech therapist friend, she is fabulous and helped me with Coly. Another, idea you could label items around your house, it helps them with learning to read and spell.
We have had everything labeled since he got here. We've had family member's laugh because our sink says sink until they realized why.
Thanks for the suggestion all the same.
And for all the encouragement!
Post a Comment